Procedure Volume Patient Data Patient Conditions Reviews General Payments Back to Top

Home > IN Providers > Facial Plastic Surgeons

Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO

(1 Rating)

Specializes in: Facial Plastic Surgery and Otolaryngology (Ear, Nose, and Throat)

2203 45th Street Suite 'b'
Highland, IN 46322

(219) 836-4820

Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO is a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN specializing in facial plastic surgery and otolaryngology (ear, nose, and throat).

Office Locations

2203 45th Street Suite 'b'
Highland, IN 46322

(219) 836-4820

(219) 836-5186

open_in_new

In The News

“Bethany Cataldi, DO, of Indiana was sentenced to just over 8 years in prison and will have to pay $19 million in restitution for billing Medicare for balloon sinuplasty procedures that she didn't...”—"Doctor Killed in Shark Attack; Nurse Fights for License; Doc Scammed Out of $500K", MedPage Today, February 2026

Noteworthy Medicare Patient Procedures Performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO in 2023

Click on any procedure below to see further details on volume and pricing among Medicare patients.

Top 5%

By Volume:

acoustic reflex testing

mastoid debridement

By Affordability:

acoustic reflex decay testing

sinuplasty

In 2023, among providers in related specialties within Indiana, Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO performed more acoustic reflex testing, and mastoid debridement procedures for Medicare patients than 95% of them and she also had a list price for acoustic reflex decay (ARD) testing, and sinuplasty that was lower than the list prices billed to Medicare by 95% of them. Actual amounts paid by patients can vary widely depending on a number of factors, including insurance coverage. A lower list price, however, might mean lower fees when paying without insurance.

Top 10%

By Volume:

diagnostic procedures

In 2023, Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO performed more diagnostic procedures procedures for Medicare patients than 90% of providers in related specialties within Indiana.

Top 25%

By Volume:

ear procedures

maxillofacial CT scan

By Affordability:

CT scan

diagnostic flexible laryngoscopy

diagnostic laryngoscopy

fiberoptic laryngoscopy

flexible laryngoscopy

laryngeal procedures

laryngoscopy

maxillofacial CT scan

In 2012, among providers in related specialties within Indiana, Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO performed more ear procedures, and maxillofacial (jaw/face) CT scan procedures for Medicare patients than 75% of them and she also had a list price for CT scan, diagnostic flexible laryngoscopy, diagnostic laryngoscopy, fiberoptic laryngoscopy, flexible laryngoscopy, laryngeal (voice box) procedures, laryngoscopy, and maxillofacial (jaw/face) CT scan that was lower than the list prices billed to Medicare by 75% of them. Actual amounts paid by patients can vary widely depending on a number of factors, including insurance coverage. A lower list price, however, might mean lower fees when paying without insurance.

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2012 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated as a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN during 2012 were ear procedures, foreign body removal, minimally invasive procedures and laryngeal (voice box) procedures.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO for Medicare patients.

debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue)	59
doctor visit	1901
ear procedures	328
foreign body removal	231
laryngeal (voice box) procedures	83
minimally invasive procedures	83
nosebleed treatment	21

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2013 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated as a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN during 2013 were ear procedures, foreign body removal, minimally invasive procedures and laryngeal (voice box) procedures.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO for Medicare patients.

debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue)	152
doctor visit	2379
ear procedures	484
foreign body removal	296
laryngeal (voice box) procedures	176
minimally invasive procedures	191
nose surgery	15
nosebleed treatment	50
plastic surgery procedures	36
reconstructive surgery	36
tissue transfer	36
wound repair (e.g. stitches)	36

2013 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO.

**Gender**
Male	283
Female	411

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	555
Black	62
Hispanic	64
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	272
From 75 to 84	225
85 and over	123
Less than 65	74

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO in 2013

Hypertension	73
High Cholesterol	62
Stroke	7
Ischemic Heart Disease	44
Depression	14
Chronic Kidney Disease	17
Asthma	10
Osteoperosis	6
Atrial Fibrilation	8
Heart Failure	22
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	19
Diabetes	33
Dementia	9
Cancer	12

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2014 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated as a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN during 2014 were ear procedures, minimally invasive procedures, debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue) and foreign body removal.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO for Medicare patients.

debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue)	259
diagnostic procedures	133
doctor visit	2320
ear procedures	616
excision	35
foreign body removal	253
gynecologic procedures	19
laryngeal (voice box) procedures	216
minimally invasive procedures	262
nose surgery	46
nosebleed treatment	75
plastic surgery procedures	100
reconstructive surgery	100
removal of lesion (e.g. growth)	35
soft tissue surgery	16
tissue transfer	100
vascular procedures	16
wound repair (e.g. stitches)	100

2014 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO.

**Gender**
Male	247
Female	349

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	489
Black	48
Hispanic	44
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	233
From 75 to 84	196
85 and over	107
Less than 65	60

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO in 2014

Hypertension	73
High Cholesterol	62
Stroke	6
Ischemic Heart Disease	46
Depression	15
Chronic Kidney Disease	19
Asthma	9
Osteoperosis	9
Atrial Fibrilation	9
Heart Failure	21
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	21
Diabetes	32
Dementia	9
Cancer	10

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2015 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated as a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN during 2015 were ear procedures, diagnostic procedures, minimally invasive procedures and foreign body removal.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO for Medicare patients.

debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue)	166
diagnostic procedures	257
doctor visit	1888
ear procedures	685
excision	13
foreign body removal	203
laryngeal (voice box) procedures	130
minimally invasive procedures	234
nose surgery	104
nosebleed treatment	34
plastic surgery procedures	32
reconstructive surgery	32
removal of lesion (e.g. growth)	13
soft tissue surgery	13
tissue transfer	32
vascular procedures	13
wound repair (e.g. stitches)	32

2015 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO.

**Gender**
Male	404
Female	584

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	790
Black	94
Hispanic	78
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	388
From 75 to 84	320
85 and over	176
Less than 65	104

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO in 2015

Hypertension	72
High Cholesterol	66
Stroke	6
Ischemic Heart Disease	43
Depression	16
Chronic Kidney Disease	20
Asthma	15
Osteoperosis	10
Atrial Fibrilation	9
Heart Failure	19
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	20
Diabetes	34
Dementia	9
Cancer	10

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2016 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated as a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN during 2016 were ear procedures, minimally invasive procedures, nose surgery and diagnostic procedures.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO for Medicare patients.

CT scan	35
debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue)	170
diagnostic procedures	258
doctor visit	1750
ear procedures	592
excision	35
foreign body removal	148
gynecologic procedures	15
laryngeal (voice box) procedures	46
minimally invasive procedures	417
nose surgery	408
nosebleed treatment	20
plastic surgery procedures	46
reconstructive surgery	46
removal of lesion (e.g. growth)	35
soft tissue surgery	20
submucous resection (SMR)	37
tissue transfer	46
vascular procedures	20
wound repair (e.g. stitches)	46

2016 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO.

**Gender**
Male	142
Female	213

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	293
Black	30
Hispanic	0
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	150
From 75 to 84	112
85 and over	52
Less than 65	41

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO in 2016

Hypertension	72
High Cholesterol	63
Stroke	4
Ischemic Heart Disease	42
Depression	23
Chronic Kidney Disease	28
Asthma	26
Osteoperosis	10
Atrial Fibrilation	11
Heart Failure	20
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	23
Diabetes	33
Dementia	8
Cancer	9

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2017 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated as a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN during 2017 were nose surgery, minimally invasive procedures, ear procedures and diagnostic procedures.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO for Medicare patients.

CT scan	63
debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue)	70
diagnostic procedures	166
doctor visit	939
ear procedures	345
excision	12
foreign body removal	77
gynecologic procedures	12
laryngeal (voice box) procedures	21
minimally invasive procedures	367
nose surgery	373
nosebleed treatment	15
plastic surgery procedures	13
reconstructive surgery	13
removal of lesion (e.g. growth)	12
submucous resection (SMR)	14
tissue transfer	13
wound repair (e.g. stitches)	13

2017 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO.

**Gender**
Male	79
Female	114

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	159
Black	19
Hispanic	0
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	76
From 75 to 84	63
85 and over	30
Less than 65	24

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO in 2017

Hypertension	75
High Cholesterol	59
Stroke	0
Ischemic Heart Disease	43
Depression	25
Chronic Kidney Disease	28
Asthma	7
Osteoperosis	10
Atrial Fibrilation	11
Heart Failure	22
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	24
Diabetes	32
Dementia	9
Cancer	8

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2018 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated as a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN during 2018 were nose surgery, minimally invasive procedures, ear procedures and debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue).

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO for Medicare patients.

CT scan	68
debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue)	298
diagnostic procedures	256
doctor visit	1404
ear procedures	654
excision	33
foreign body removal	91
gynecologic procedures	22
laryngeal (voice box) procedures	38
minimally invasive procedures	830
nose surgery	864
nosebleed treatment	91
plastic surgery procedures	42
reconstructive surgery	42
removal of lesion (e.g. growth)	22
submucous resection (SMR)	60
tissue transfer	42
wound repair (e.g. stitches)	42

2018 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO.

**Gender**
Male	119
Female	167

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	244
Black	22
Hispanic	0
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	127
From 75 to 84	94
85 and over	41
Less than 65	24

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO in 2018

Hypertension	74
High Cholesterol	68
Stroke	6
Ischemic Heart Disease	40
Depression	23
Chronic Kidney Disease	31
Asthma	11
Osteoperosis	10
Atrial Fibrilation	13
Heart Failure	24
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	26
Diabetes	31
Dementia	12
Cancer	14

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2019 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated as a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN during 2019 were ear procedures, nose surgery, minimally invasive procedures and debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue).

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO for Medicare patients.

CT scan	123
debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue)	591
diagnostic procedures	483
doctor visit	2294
ear procedures	1180
excision	28
foreign body removal	149
gynecologic procedures	15
laryngeal (voice box) procedures	175
minimally invasive procedures	922
nose surgery	998
nosebleed treatment	150
plastic surgery procedures	88
reconstructive surgery	88
removal of lesion (e.g. growth)	28
soft tissue surgery	13
submucous resection (SMR)	251
tissue transfer	88
vascular procedures	13
wound repair (e.g. stitches)	88

2019 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO.

**Gender**
Male	174
Female	257

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	364
Black	28
Hispanic	26
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	174
From 75 to 84	153
85 and over	70
Less than 65	34

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO in 2019

Hypertension	74
High Cholesterol	68
Stroke	7
Ischemic Heart Disease	38
Depression	24
Chronic Kidney Disease	25
Asthma	8
Osteoperosis	12
Atrial Fibrilation	13
Heart Failure	21
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	23
Diabetes	28
Dementia	11
Cancer	13

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2020 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated as a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN during 2020 were ear procedures, minimally invasive procedures, nose surgery and debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue).

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO for Medicare patients.

CT scan	87
debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue)	431
diagnostic procedures	416
doctor visit	1541
ear procedures	1215
excision	15
foreign body removal	383
laryngeal (voice box) procedures	255
minimally invasive procedures	828
nose surgery	742
nosebleed treatment	128
plastic surgery procedures	125
reconstructive surgery	125
removal of lesion (e.g. growth)	15
soft tissue surgery	15
submucous resection (SMR)	156
tissue transfer	125
vascular procedures	15
wound repair (e.g. stitches)	125

2020 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO.

**Gender**
Male	210
Female	328

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	456
Black	36
Hispanic	33
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	204
From 75 to 84	191
85 and over	98
Less than 65	45

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO in 2020

Hypertension	72
High Cholesterol	65
Stroke	5
Ischemic Heart Disease	40
Depression	21
Chronic Kidney Disease	30
Asthma	7
Osteoperosis	11
Atrial Fibrilation	12
Heart Failure	20
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	20
Diabetes	26
Dementia	12
Cancer	14

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2021 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated as a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN during 2021 were ear procedures, nose surgery, minimally invasive procedures and diagnostic procedures.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO for Medicare patients.

CT scan	21
debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue)	30
diagnostic procedures	96
doctor visit	364
ear procedures	145
foreign body removal	19
laryngeal (voice box) procedures	41
minimally invasive procedures	138
nose surgery	139
nosebleed treatment	15
submucous resection (SMR)	42

2021 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO.

**Gender**
Male	84
Female	105

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	157
Black	19
Hispanic	0
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	77
From 75 to 84	73
85 and over	0
Less than 65	0

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO in 2021

Hypertension	75
High Cholesterol	67
Stroke	6
Ischemic Heart Disease	40
Depression	24
Chronic Kidney Disease	32
Asthma	7
Osteoperosis	10
Atrial Fibrilation	13
Heart Failure	21
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	19
Diabetes	35
Dementia	14
Cancer	20

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2022 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated as a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN during 2022 were ear procedures, diagnostic procedures, minimally invasive procedures and debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue).

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO for Medicare patients.

CT scan	75
debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue)	121
diagnostic procedures	187
doctor visit	671
ear procedures	354
foreign body removal	46
laryngeal (voice box) procedures	44
minimally invasive procedures	140
nose surgery	96
nosebleed treatment	18

2022 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO.

**Gender**
Male	164
Female	238

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	343
Black	25
Hispanic	20
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	158
From 75 to 84	150
85 and over	73
Less than 65	21

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO in 2022

Hypertension	75
High Cholesterol	75
Stroke	7
Ischemic Heart Disease	31
Depression	18
Chronic Kidney Disease	20
Asthma	9
Osteoperosis	19
Atrial Fibrilation	15
Heart Failure	16
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	19
Diabetes	31
Dementia	7
Cancer	17

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

Average Medicare Procedure Volume From 2012 - 2022

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO for Medicare patients.

The highest averages for the top procedures that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated as a facial plastic surgeon in Highland, IN were ear procedures, minimally invasive procedures, nose surgery and diagnostic procedures.

CT scan	67
debridement (removal of unhealthy tissue)	213
diagnostic procedures	250
doctor visit	1586
ear procedures	599
excision	24
foreign body removal	172
gynecologic procedures	16
laryngeal (voice box) procedures	111
minimally invasive procedures	401
nose surgery	378
nosebleed treatment	56
plastic surgery procedures	60
reconstructive surgery	60
removal of lesion (e.g. growth)	22
soft tissue surgery	15
submucous resection (SMR)	93
tissue transfer	60
vascular procedures	15
wound repair (e.g. stitches)	60

Average Medicare Patient Data From 2012 - 2022

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO.

**Gender**
Male	173
Female	251

**Ethnicity**
Black / African American	34
Asian / Pacific Islander	0
Non-Hispanic White	350
Native American / Alaskan Native	0
Hispanic	24
Other	0

**Age**
75 to 84	143
85 and over	70
Less than 65	38
65 to 74	169

Average of Total of Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO From 2012 - 2022

The highest averages of the most common conditions of Medicare patients that Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO treated were hypertension, high cholesterol, ischemic heart disease and diabetes.

Hypertension	66
High Cholesterol	59
Stroke	4
Ischemic Heart Disease	37
Depression	18
Chronic Kidney Disease	22
Asthma	9
Osteoporosis	9
Heart Failure	18
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	19
Diabetes	28
Atrial Fibrillation	10
Dementia	9
Cancer	11

Education & Training

She has a state license in Indiana.

Licensed In: Indiana

Ratings & Reviews

Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO has an exceptional overall rating with an average of 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 1 ratings. We collect ratings and reviews of Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO from all over the web to help you find the right in Highland, IN.

Overall Rating

(1 Rating)

Leave a Review

Reviews Left On DocSpot

Overall Rating: 5.0 2021-01-26

I had been suffering from chronic sinus problems for the last 5 years and Dr. Cataldi has helped me breathe better after my surgery with her. She's attentive to patients' problems and she really listens. A true gem of a doctor!

General Payments

These charts describe general payments received by Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO. Doctors may receive payments for a number of reasons, including meal compensation, travel compensation, and consulting.

**Payments by Company**
Lupin Pharmaceuticals, Inc	$148 AeroMaskLarge $138	Suprax $10
Horizon Pharma USA, Inc.	$106 DUEXIS-800mg Ibuprofen- 26.6mg Famotidine $81	Duexis $24
Horizon Pharma plc	$49 RAYOS $25	Duexis $24
Par Pharmaceutical, Inc.	$45 CORTISPORIN-TC $45
Meda Pharmaceuticals, Inc.	$44 Dymista $44
Other	$187 ENT $36	Otovel $31	Rhinology $24	EpiPen $24	Suprax $16	Other $56

**Types of Payments**
Food and Beverage	$579

Biography

Dr. Bethany Cataldi specializes in facial plastic surgery and otolaryngology (ear, nose, and throat) and practices in Highland, IN. She is a graduate of Midwestern University, Chicago College of Osteopathic Medicine.